Walmart reported a drop in sales as US consumer spending retreated, the company said on August 20 — a significant signal given that Walmart’s data tends to be one of the most reliable leading indicators of mass-market consumer confidence in the United States. The same day, NPR reported that the bond market is signalling trouble ahead, with analysts warning that rising yields on Treasury bonds reflect growing investor anxiety about a combination of sticky inflation, ballooning federal debt, and the economic aftermath of the Iran war and its tariff cascades. The US national debt crossed $40 trillion earlier this week — having doubled in a decade — and NPR noted three critical dynamics that make this milestone more than symbolic. Separately, the BBC noted that the US economy is ringing alarm bells as inflation remains elevated and consumer resilience — the great engine of American economic growth — shows genuine signs of exhaustion.
The received wisdom
The progressive framing of US economic anxiety places primary blame on Republican tax policy — specifically the Trump-era tax cuts of 2017 and their 2025 extensions — combined with military spending in the Iran conflict and the self-inflicted damage of tariff wars. In this account, the $40 trillion debt is a direct consequence of fiscal irresponsibility concentrated on the right, and the appropriate response is revenue-raising: higher taxes on corporations and the wealthy, closure of investment income loopholes, and restraint on military adventurism. The Walmart sales slowdown reflects the cumulative toll of tariff-driven inflation on working-class households — the very constituency the administration claims to champion. Bonds are sounding the alarm because investors can see a debt trajectory without a credible stabilisation plan.
This reading has genuine force. The 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act did not pay for itself in growth, as its proponents claimed it would. And the combination of a major war plus sustained tariff policy is a structurally inflationary mix. These are real inputs to the current anxiety.
A different read
Where the progressive framing falls short is in its implicit suggestion that the solution is primarily distributional — tax the rich more, and the fiscal problem resolves. The US structural deficit problem predates the Trump tax cuts and, more importantly, is driven by mandatory spending categories that neither party has shown willingness to address. Social Security and Medicare together account for roughly forty per cent of the federal budget. Their actuarial trajectories — driven by demographics rather than ideology — are the central long-term driver of the debt increase. The conversation that neither party is having is about entitlement reform.
NPR’s reporting on the $40 trillion milestone notes that the debt has doubled in a decade — which spans two Republican and one Democratic administrations. This is bipartisan fiscal profligacy, not partisan sabotage. Both parties have consistently chosen to spend more than they collect and to defer the reckoning, because the reckoning is politically costly to whichever party is unlucky enough to preside over it.
The bond market signal deserves particular attention. When investors demand higher yields on government debt, they are saying one of two things: either they expect inflation to persist (and therefore want compensation for the erosion of their principal), or they are beginning to doubt the US government’s capacity to manage its debt load (a “fiscal risk premium”). For most of the post-war period, US Treasuries were priced as the risk-free asset — the baseline against which all other risk was measured. A sustained fiscal risk premium on Treasuries would represent a structural change in global finance with consequences for every borrower, every pension fund, and every government that prices its debt off the US Treasury curve.
The Walmart signal is qualitatively different but pointing in the same direction. Walmart’s consumer base skews toward households with limited financial buffers — the 60th percentile of income and below. When those households pull back, it is not an optional lifestyle adjustment; it reflects genuine pressure from the combination of higher prices, higher borrowing costs, and reduced real wage growth. The Iran war’s impact on oil prices has flowed through to food and energy costs in ways that disproportionately affect exactly these households. The administration’s defenders will note that employment remains high, which is true; but high employment combined with consumer spending retreat suggests that wages are not keeping pace with inflation in the categories that matter most to lower-income consumers.
The historical moment worth invoking is the late 1970s: high inflation, energy price shocks, consumer fatigue, and a federal government whose credibility on fiscal management was in doubt. Paul Volcker’s solution — extremely painful monetary tightening — broke the inflationary psychology but produced a deep recession first. The Federal Reserve today faces a structurally similar dilemma: premature rate cuts risk re-igniting inflation; sustained high rates risk tipping a consumer-spending-led economy into recession. There is no comfortable path through this.
Conservatives should resist the temptation to blame this entirely on Democrats — the debt doubled under Trump as well as under Biden — and should instead press for the politically uncomfortable conversation about mandatory spending that neither party will initiate voluntarily. The alarm bells are ringing. The question is whether anyone in Washington is listening.
What to watch
- Federal Reserve meeting minutes and forward guidance: any signal that the Fed is considering rate cuts to support growth will immediately test whether it can do so without reigniting inflation, given the structural inflationary pressures from tariffs and energy costs.
- Holiday season retail data, beginning in October: if Walmart’s August signal is confirmed by broader retail data, the administration faces a politically damaging consumer economy story heading into the November midterms.
- The 10-year Treasury yield: if it approaches or breaches 5.5% on a sustained basis, expect significant pressure on mortgage markets, corporate refinancing, and the federal government’s own debt service costs — which are already the fourth-largest federal expenditure category.
- Whether Congress’s budget reconciliation process includes any serious entitlement reform language — the absence of which would tell investors that Washington has no credible path to fiscal stabilisation.
— J