West Bank settlements and the limits of allied condemnation

The United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, and Canada have jointly condemned Israel’s announcement of a major new West Bank settlement expansion, issuing what diplomats described as some of the most forceful collective language from Jerusalem’s traditional allies in recent memory. The statement warned that the settlement project — which would involve the construction of thousands of new housing units in areas that international law regards as occupied Palestinian territory — constitutes a violation of UN Security Council Resolution 2334 and undermines the viability of any future two-state solution. The US administration, which has been more permissive of Israeli settlement activity than any of its predecessors, did not join the statement. Israel’s government dismissed the condemnation as interference in sovereign decisions and announced it would proceed with the project.

The received wisdom

The mainstream progressive view sees the allied condemnation as overdue but welcome — a sign that even Jerusalem’s closest European partners have reached a threshold of tolerance for Israeli settlement policy. In this framing, the expansion of Israeli presence in the West Bank is the primary obstacle to a two-state solution, and the international community’s failure to impose consequences for settlement activity has enabled a creeping annexation that makes a viable Palestinian state increasingly geographically impossible. The Biden administration’s occasional criticism of settlements was insufficient; the Trump administration’s posture amounts to active complicity. The five-nation statement is thus framed as a reassertion of international legal norms by democracies that have the standing and the obligation to uphold them.

This reading is not wrong about the legal framework. Resolution 2334, passed with US abstention under Obama in 2016, is clear: Israeli settlement activity in occupied Palestinian territory has no legal validity and constitutes a flagrant violation of international law. The settlements fragment Palestinian territory in ways that are not easily reversible.

A different read

What makes this condemnation analytically interesting is not whether the five governments are legally correct — they largely are — but what it reveals about the structural gap between statement and consequence in contemporary European diplomacy.

Consider the track record. European powers have been issuing statements condemning Israeli settlement expansion for more than thirty years, through the Oslo process, the Roadmap, the Quartet negotiations, the Kerry initiative, and multiple rounds of UN resolutions. The settlements have grown, by every measure, throughout this period. The settler population in the West Bank, which was under 250,000 at Oslo in 1993, is now estimated to exceed 700,000. Diplomatic statements without enforcement mechanisms are not foreign policy; they are the appearance of foreign policy.

The five governments that signed this statement have real tools available if they choose to use them. The European Union is Israel’s largest trading partner. Individual EU member states hold substantial bilateral investment and academic exchange relationships. The UK’s trade relationship with Israel, still governed partly by the EU-Israel Association Agreement framework, creates legal leverage. None of these instruments has been deployed, and none appears close to deployment. The statement is designed to register disapproval while preserving the relationship — which is a legitimate diplomatic choice, but one whose strategic logic should be stated openly rather than obscured behind the language of international norms.

There is also a harder conversation that the right should be willing to have directly: the settlement enterprise is not simply a technical violation of international law. It is a policy — supported by successive Israeli governments of both left and right — that has over thirty years systematically reduced the territorial basis for a Palestinian state to the point where many serious analysts now question whether a two-state solution remains physically possible. The Israeli right’s answer to this is that the Palestinian Authority has rejected every serious two-state offer made to it, which is historically contestable but not entirely wrong. The left’s answer is that continued occupation and settlement expansion make any future negotiation moot, which is increasingly difficult to dispute empirically.

The more conservative and honest position is this: Israel has the right to security and self-determination; so, in principle, do Palestinians; the settlement enterprise as currently practised makes the exercise of both increasingly irreconcilable; and allies who want to be taken seriously must eventually back statements with costs, or acknowledge that they have made a choice to prioritise the relationship over the principle. That is an honest position. What is not honest is pretending that statements alone constitute a meaningful foreign policy response.

The US administration’s absence from the statement is the other significant data point. A joint UK-France-Germany-Italy-Canada statement without Washington is a statement that the Trump administration has declined to participate in. The five governments know this. They also know that Israeli settlement policy now has the active support of the United States in a way it has not had since the 1970s. The statement is thus partly addressed to a domestic European audience, not solely to Jerusalem.

What to watch

  • Whether the UK or EU triggers any of the existing legal mechanisms available for reviewing trade preferences when parties violate international humanitarian law — this would be the step that converts rhetoric into consequence.
  • The Israeli government’s construction timeline: if groundbreaking begins within sixty days of the condemnation with no material response from the five governments, the statement will have had the opposite of its intended effect.
  • The Palestinian Authority’s position: Ramallah has been in an increasingly weakened state, and any new large-scale settlement announcement further undermines the PA’s domestic credibility and strengthens Hamas’s political argument that diplomacy is futile.
  • Whether the ICC — which the US is currently sanctioning — pursues the settlement expansion as part of its ongoing investigation into the situation in Palestine, and how the five signatory states respond to such a move.

— J